The first properly cold nights have arrived in Toronto, which means it’s time for drinks served in mugs. Hot cocktails are simple, but they go wrong in predictable ways: too sweet, too weak, or boiled until the alcohol and flavour have gone. A few ratios and one temperature rule fix all of that.

The one rule: never boil

Alcohol boils at about 78 °C, well below water’s 100 °C, and it evaporates quickly long before that. Boil a hot cocktail and you lose both the alcohol and the delicate flavours, and the spices turn bitter. Heat until it’s steaming, not bubbling.

Two other habits help. Warm the mug first by filling it with hot water for a minute and tipping it out; a cold mug takes the heat straight out of the drink. And for batches, a slow cooker on the low or keep-warm setting holds a drink at a perfect temperature all evening without any risk of boiling.

The hot toddy

1½ oz whisky · ½ oz fresh lemon · ½ to ¾ oz honey · 4 oz hot water

Put the honey in the warmed mug and dissolve it with a splash of the hot water first; honey doesn’t dissolve well in alcohol. Add the whisky and lemon, top with the rest of the hot water, and stir. Garnish with a lemon wheel studded with a few cloves, or a cinnamon stick.

Canadian whisky makes a soft, smooth toddy. Jameson gives a lighter, fruitier one. A blended Scotch like Johnnie Walker Red Label adds a little smoke. Avoid heavily peated whisky, which turns medicinal when heated.

Fresh lemon is essential. The lemons in the photo above are not decoration.

Spiked apple cider

1½ oz spiced rum or whisky · 5 oz fresh apple cider · cinnamon stick · squeeze of lemon

Heat the cider in a pan with the cinnamon stick until steaming, pour into a warm mug, add the spirit and a squeeze of lemon. Spiced rum like Captain Morgan Original Spiced leans into the spice; Canadian whisky makes it drier and rounder. Use fresh, cloudy cider rather than clear apple juice.

If you made cinnamon syrup for our fall cocktails, a quarter ounce here is a good addition.

Irish coffee, done properly

1½ oz Irish whiskey · 2 tsp brown sugar · 4 oz hot, strong coffee · lightly whipped cream

  1. Warm a heatproof glass or mug.
  2. Dissolve the brown sugar in the hot coffee, then add the whiskey.
  3. Whip cold heavy cream just until it thickens slightly but still pours. It shouldn’t hold stiff peaks.
  4. Pour the cream slowly over the back of a spoon so it floats in a thick layer on top.

Don’t stir. The point is to drink the hot, sweet coffee through the cold cream. The sugar matters: it makes the coffee dense enough to float the cream. Without it, the cream sinks. Jameson is the natural whiskey for it.

Hot buttered rum

Batter: 115 g soft butter · 100 g brown sugar · 1 tsp cinnamon · ¼ tsp nutmeg · pinch of clove and salt

Mash the batter ingredients together; it keeps in the fridge for two weeks. For each drink, put a heaped tablespoon of batter in a warm mug with 2 oz dark or spiced rum, top with 4 oz hot water and stir until the butter melts. Rich, spiced, and a drink for the coldest nights of the year rather than every night.

Mulled wine for a crowd

750 ml red wine · 1 orange, sliced · 2 cinnamon sticks · 4 cloves · 2 star anise · 50 to 75 g sugar or honey · optional: 2 oz brandy

Put everything in a pan or slow cooker and warm gently, never boiling, for 20 to 30 minutes until it’s steaming and the spices have infused. Taste, and add sugar a little at a time. Add the brandy at the end if you’re using it. Use a fruity, inexpensive red like Gato Negro Cabernet Sauvignon; expensive wine is wasted here, but sour or bad wine still tastes bad hot.

One bottle makes about six small mugs. Double or triple it in a slow cooker for a party.

A word on safety

Hot drinks and alcohol need a little more care than cold ones. Keep pans on a back burner and don’t leave a stove unattended. If you flame anything, which none of these recipes require, keep the bottle well away. Hot drinks also go down quickly on a cold night, and they’re no less strong for being warm, so pace accordingly.

The short version

Heat to steaming, never boiling. Warm the mugs. A toddy is whisky, lemon, honey and hot water; Irish coffee needs sugar to float the cream; mulled wine and cider belong in a slow cooker on low.

Whisky, rum and wine are on the menu, and we deliver across Toronto and the GTA. Call or text (416) 988-3623. The full whisky range is on our whisky page.