Rum is distilled from sugarcane, almost always from molasses, the thick syrup left over after sugar is made. Beyond that, the rules are loose. Rum is made all over the Caribbean, Latin America and beyond, and each country has its own traditions, which is why two bottles labelled “rum” can taste nothing alike.
The colour on the label is the most useful guide you have. Here’s what each type is, and what to do with it.
White rum
Also sold as silver or light rum. Most white rum is aged briefly in barrels and then filtered through charcoal to strip the colour back out, which leaves a clean, light spirit with a little sweetness and not much else.
That neutrality is the point. White rum is a mixer: it carries citrus, mint and sugar without getting in the way. Bacardi White is the reference bottle.
Make with it: daiquiris, mojitos, piña coladas, and rum and soda with a lot of lime.
The daiquiri
2 parts white rum · 1 part fresh lime · ¾ part sugar syrup
Shake hard with ice and strain into a chilled glass. If you only learn one rum drink, make it this one.
Gold rum
Gold (or amber) rum has spent longer in oak, picking up colour along with soft vanilla, caramel and toffee notes. Some gold rums also get a little caramel colouring to keep the shade consistent.
It sits between white and dark: still a mixer, but one with enough character to taste of something in a long drink. Bacardi Gold is a good, everyday example.
Make with it: rum and cola with a big squeeze of lime (a Cuba libre), rum punch, and anything with pineapple.
Spiced rum
Spiced rum is rum flavoured after distillation with spices and other flavourings, typically vanilla, cinnamon, clove and orange peel, and usually sweetened. It’s the most approachable style for people who don’t think they like rum.
Captain Morgan Original Spiced is the best-known bottle in Canada. Because it’s already sweet and spiced, it doesn’t need much help.
Make with it: spiced rum and ginger ale, spiced rum and cola, and hot or cold apple cider. In cocktails that call for plain rum, cut back on the sugar syrup to compensate.
Dark rum
Dark or black rum gets its colour from longer ageing, added molasses or caramel, or all three. The flavour is heavier: burnt sugar, dried fruit, coffee and spice. Navy rums, the blends once rationed to British sailors, belong in this family.
Make with it: the dark and stormy, rum punch where you want depth, and a float on top of a tiki drink.
The dark and stormy
2 parts dark rum · ginger beer · lime
Fill a tall glass with ice and ginger beer, then float the rum on top so it sinks slowly through. Ginger beer, not ginger ale: you need the bite.
Aged rum
Aged rums are the sipping end of the category, rested in oak for years and judged more like whisky. Jamaican rums are known for their bold, fruity, almost funky character, a result of slow fermentation and pot stills. Appleton is the classic Jamaican name, and it works both in a mai tai and over a single ice cube.
Age statements on rum don’t follow one global rule, so read them as a rough guide rather than a guarantee. Trust your palate over the number.
The mai tai
2 parts aged rum · ¾ part fresh lime · ½ part orange curaçao · ½ part orgeat
Shake with crushed or cracked ice and pour everything into a rocks glass. Mint sprig on top. No pineapple juice, no grenadine. That’s a different (and lesser) drink.
Two specialists worth knowing
Rhum agricole is made from fresh sugarcane juice rather than molasses, mainly in the French Caribbean. It tastes grassy and vegetal, nothing like the sweet rum most people know. Try it in a ti’ punch: rhum agricole, a coin of lime, a little cane syrup, no ice or one cube.
Overproof rum is bottled well above the usual 40%, often around 57% or more. Use it in small measures to give tiki drinks backbone, never neat by the glass. It is flammable, so leave the flaming cocktails to bartenders with fire training.
Which bottle should you buy?
- One bottle only: a good gold rum. It covers mixed drinks and punch, and it’s pleasant enough neat.
- Cocktails: white for daiquiris and mojitos, plus an aged Jamaican rum for mai tais and stirred drinks.
- Easy drinking with mixers: spiced.
- Winter: dark rum for hot buttered rum and stormy weather of every kind.
Rum keeps indefinitely once opened, so a second or third bottle is never wasted. The full range is on our rum page.
The short version
White rum is a clean mixer for citrus drinks. Gold rum has a little oak and suits long drinks and punch. Spiced is sweet and flavoured, made for ginger ale and cola. Dark is heavy and rich. Aged rum is for sipping and serious cocktails.
All of the bottles above are on the menu, and we deliver across Toronto and the GTA. Call or text (416) 988-3623. For more ratio-based drinks, see our three-ingredient cocktails.



