Halloween falls on a Saturday this year, October 31, which means a lot of costume parties across the GTA. The drinks for a party like that should do three things: look dramatic, make themselves (nobody wants to tend bar dressed as a vampire), and come in large quantities.
Here are five batch drinks, the maths for making them, and the safe way to get that smoky look.
The batch maths
Two numbers make batching easy.
- Dilution: a shaken drink is about 20 to 25% melted ice. A batched drink served over ice needs some of that water added in advance, or it tastes harsh. Add roughly a fifth of the total volume as cold water, or use juice or soda for the same job.
- Servings: a 750 ml bottle of spirit at 40% contains about 17 standard drinks. Whatever you mix it with, the bowl holds about 17 drinks’ worth of alcohol. Divide by the number of guests to see how far it goes.
Mix the batch a few hours ahead and chill it. Serve over a big block of ice (freeze water in a loaf tin) rather than cubes, which melt fast and water everything down.
Dark rum punch
There’s an old Caribbean rhyme for punch: one of sour, two of sweet, three of strong, four of weak.
250 ml fresh lime · 500 ml sugar syrup · 750 ml gold or dark rum · 1 L water or fruit juice
Mix, chill, serve over a block of ice with nutmeg grated on top. Cut the syrup by a third if you’re using sweet juice. A dark rum gives it a deep amber colour that suits the night. This makes about 16 servings.
Dark and stormy by the pitcher
1 part dark rum · 2½ parts ginger beer · lime wedges
Fill the glasses with ice and ginger beer, then pour the rum slowly over the back of a spoon so it floats in a dark layer on top. In a pitcher, mix it all and it loses the layered look, so set out the ingredients and let people build their own. The effect is the point.
Spiced rum cider punch
750 ml spiced rum · 1.5 L apple cider · 250 ml fresh lemon · 500 ml ginger ale
Mix the rum, cider and lemon in advance. Add the ginger ale and ice just before serving. Float thin apple slices and cinnamon sticks on top. Captain Morgan Original Spiced is made for this. About 18 servings.
The blue one
1½ oz white rum · ½ oz blue curaçao · 2 oz pineapple juice · ½ oz fresh lime
Shake with ice and strain, or batch it in a jug with a fifth extra water. The colour is unnatural in exactly the right way for Halloween. Bacardi White keeps it clean and bright.
A cranberry margarita jug
500 ml blanco tequila · 250 ml orange liqueur · 250 ml fresh lime · 250 ml cranberry juice · 250 ml cold water
Stir together and chill. The cranberry turns it a deep blood red. Serve over ice with a salt rim. About 12 servings. Our tequila guide explains why fresh lime matters so much here.
Dry ice: how to use it safely
Dry ice is frozen carbon dioxide at about minus 78 °C, and it produces the fog you see in the photo. It looks great and it can cause serious injuries if handled carelessly.
- Never put dry ice pieces in a drink someone will drink. A swallowed or touched piece can cause severe burns inside the mouth and throat. The fog-in-the-glass look should come from a separate container.
- Use two bowls. Put dry ice and warm water in a larger outer bowl, and set the punch bowl inside it. You get the fog around the drink, not in it.
- Handle it with gloves or tongs. Bare skin contact causes frostbite in seconds.
- Ventilate. It releases carbon dioxide gas. Don’t use it in a small closed room, and never store it in a sealed container.
- Keep it away from children and pets.
Hosting with trick-or-treaters around
If there are kids at the door or at the party, label the adult punch clearly, keep it away from the candy table, and make a non-alcoholic version in a different colour so nobody mixes them up. Cranberry and soda, or apple cider with cinnamon, both look festive without the rum.
Timing for a Saturday party
Licensed delivery and retail sales in Ontario stop at 11 p.m., and Halloween parties tend to warm up just as that time approaches. Order early in the evening. For quantities, our guide to how much alcohol to buy for a party works for costume parties too.
The short version
Batch everything, add a fifth of the volume as water, serve over a block of ice, and keep dry ice in an outer bowl, never in a glass. Dark rum punch for depth, the blue drink for show.
Rum, tequila and the mixers are on the menu, and we deliver across Toronto and the GTA. Call or text (416) 988-3623. For simpler drinks, see our three-ingredient cocktails.



