Every September the Toronto International Film Festival takes over downtown: closed streets around King, queues around the block, and a lot of people deciding that the best seat in the city is their own couch. If you’re hosting a movie night this month, the drinks deserve the same thought as the film.

The rules are a little different from a dinner party. The lights are off, nobody wants to get up mid-scene, and you’re pairing with popcorn rather than a main course. Here’s what works.

Match the drink to the film

The mood of the film matters more than the menu.

A slow drama

Something to sip and think about. A medium-bodied red like Gato Negro Cabernet Sauvignon, or a measure of whisky neat. You want a drink that lasts two hours without needing a refill every twenty minutes.

A tense thriller

Something that sits happily in the hand during the bits where you forget to drink. An old fashioned holds up as it dilutes, and a cold beer stays good even if it warms a little.

A big comedy

Lighter, colder, easier. A crisp white such as Peller Family Pinot Grigio, a rosé, or a lager. Comedy is a group sport and the drinks should be too.

A festival oddity you’ve never heard of

Sparkling. Bubbles make anything feel like an event, and if the film turns out to be three hours of a lighthouse, at least the drink was good.

Wine and popcorn pairings that actually work

Popcorn is salty, fatty and crunchy, which makes it far more wine-friendly than its reputation.

  • Butter and salt: a round white with some body. Chardonnay is the classic, and a ripe Pinot Grigio works too. Butter and buttery wines meet in the middle.
  • Just salt: sparkling wine. Salt and bubbles is one of the most reliable pairings there is. A bottle of Luc Belaire Rosé earns its place here.
  • Cheese dusting or parmesan: a fruity red with soft tannins. The cheese takes the edge off the tannin.
  • Kettle corn or caramel corn: rosé, or a fruit-forward red. Avoid very dry, tart whites, which taste sour next to sugar.
  • Spicy seasoning: an off-dry white or a cold lager. Heat and high alcohol fight each other.

Chocolate and red wine is less of a match than people assume. Dark chocolate with a big, fruity red is fine; milk chocolate with anything dry tends to make the wine taste thin.

Beyond popcorn

Most movie nights end up with more than one bowl on the table. A few pairings for the usual suspects:

  • Pizza: a medium red with good acidity, or a cold lager. Tomato sauce makes very oaky, tannic reds taste bitter, so keep it fruity.
  • Nachos and salsa: beer, and specifically a light lager with lime. Corona exists for this.
  • Chips: sparkling wine again. Salty, fried and crunchy is exactly what bubbles are good at.
  • Cheese board: red for hard cheeses like aged cheddar, white for soft ones like brie. If in doubt, a dry rosé handles both.
  • Candy: nothing dry. Sweet food makes dry wine taste sour and thin. Keep the candy for the non-drinkers and the second half.

If the snacks are heavy, lean towards lighter drinks. A full bottle of big red with a large pizza is the fastest route to falling asleep before the final act.

One jug for the whole film

Getting up to mix drinks during a film is how you miss the twist. Make one jug before the lights go down.

A rosé spritz: 3 parts rosé · 2 parts soda water · a few strawberries or an orange slice

Build it in a jug with plenty of ice and keep it in reach. It’s lower in alcohol than straight wine, so it lasts the length of a feature without anyone feeling it by the credits.

For something stronger, a jug of Negronis (equal parts gin, Campari and sweet vermouth) keeps in the fridge for days. The recipe and a few other easy ones are in our three-ingredient cocktails guide.

The quiet-night logistics

  • Open and decant before the film starts. A carafe is quieter than a corkscrew in the middle of a scene.
  • Stemless glasses. They’re harder to knock over in the dark and don’t clink against the coffee table.
  • Chill a second bottle in advance. The first bottle always goes faster than you think.
  • Put the water out too. Popcorn is very salty.
  • Order before 11 p.m. Licensed delivery in Ontario stops at 11 p.m. If you’re starting a long film at nine, sort the drinks first.

A double bill

If you’re watching two films, change the drinks at the intermission rather than carrying on with the same thing. Start lighter (white, rosé or beer) and move to red or a whisky for the second film. It keeps the evening interesting and stops anyone drifting through the second film on autopilot.

For series rather than films, our Binge & Sip guide pairs drinks with whole seasons.

The short version

Pour by mood: red or whisky for dramas, cold and light for comedies, sparkling for anything unpredictable. Salty popcorn loves bubbles, buttered popcorn loves Chardonnay. Make a jug before the lights go down and order before 11.

The wines above are on our wine page, and we deliver across Toronto and the GTA. Call or text (416) 988-3623.