Canadian Thanksgiving is Monday, October 12, and most families will sit down to dinner on the Sunday or the Monday. The good news about turkey is that it’s easy to pair with. The bad news is everything else on the table: sweet potatoes, stuffing, gravy, cranberry sauce, Brussels sprouts and three kinds of pie, all at once.
The trick is to choose wines that are flexible rather than perfect. Here’s what works.
Why Thanksgiving dinner is hard to pair
A typical wine pairing matches one dish. Thanksgiving puts sweet, savoury, sour, fatty and herbal flavours on the same plate. A wine that’s great with roast turkey can taste harsh next to cranberry sauce or flat next to candied yams.
The wines that cope best share three things: good acidity (to cut through gravy and butter), plenty of fruit (to stand up to sweet sides), and gentle tannins (because tannin clashes with cranberry and sweetness). Light to medium body, bright and fruity, not too oaky.
The reds that work
Pinot Noir
The classic Thanksgiving red. Light-bodied, red-fruited, earthy, with soft tannins. It loves turkey, mushrooms and stuffing, and it doesn’t fight the cranberry. Ontario grows very good Pinot Noir, particularly in Niagara and Prince Edward County.
Gamay
The grape of Beaujolais, and a quiet Ontario success story. Juicy, light and slightly peppery, best served a little cool. If someone at the table thinks they don’t like red wine, give them a Gamay.
Cabernet Franc
Ontario’s signature red in many people’s view. Medium-bodied, with raspberry, red pepper and herbal notes that match sage stuffing remarkably well.
Bigger reds are fine if the menu leans towards beef or a heavy stuffing. Gato Negro Cabernet Sauvignon is fruity and soft enough to handle it, but keep it away from the cranberry sauce.
The whites that work
Riesling
Possibly the best all-round Thanksgiving wine, red or white. High acidity, intense fruit, and often a touch of sweetness that makes it brilliant with sweet potatoes, squash and anything spicy. Ontario Riesling has a very good reputation. Choose dry or off-dry; save the sweet ones for dessert.
Chardonnay
Lightly oaked Chardonnay matches the richness of turkey, gravy and buttery mash. Very heavily oaked versions can taste bitter with the meal; something in the middle is the safe bet.
Crisp whites
For guests who want something light, a Pinot Grigio or Sauvignon Blanc works well with the vegetables, salads and the first hour of the evening.
Sparkling and rosé
Sparkling wine is underrated with a big dinner. The bubbles and acidity refresh the palate between rich mouthfuls, and it’s the right way to start the day anyway. A sparkling rosé like Luc Belaire Rosé covers both the toast and the turkey.
Dry rosé is the great compromise wine: enough fruit for the sweet sides, enough freshness for the gravy, and it suits people who can’t decide between red and white.
What to avoid
- Big, tannic reds with cranberry sauce. Tannin plus tart, sweet fruit tastes bitter and metallic.
- Very oaky, very buttery whites with the sweeter sides. The oak turns bitter.
- Bone-dry wines with dessert. If the wine is less sweet than the pie, the wine tastes sour. Pair pie with a sweet wine, coffee, or nothing at all.
- Very high alcohol. Dinners are long; 12 to 13.5% wines are far kinder over four hours than a 15% Zinfandel.
How much to buy
A 750 ml bottle holds five glasses of 5 oz. Over a long dinner, plan on about half a bottle per wine-drinking adult, plus a bottle of sparkling for every six or eight people for the toast. Then add a bottle or two extra: unopened wine keeps, and running out on Thanksgiving Monday is a nuisance. Our guide to party quantities has the full breakdown.
Offer a red and a white at minimum, and let guests choose. Many people switch halfway through anyway.
Serving temperatures
- Sparkling: 6 to 8 °C, straight from the fridge.
- Whites and rosé: 8 to 12 °C. Take them out of the fridge 15 minutes before dinner.
- Light reds (Pinot Noir, Gamay): 13 to 15 °C. Twenty minutes in the fridge is about right.
- Fuller reds: 16 to 18 °C. Cooler than a warm, crowded dining room.
And put out a good non-alcoholic option, like sparkling apple cider. Ontario apples are in season, and the drivers will thank you.
The short version
Pinot Noir or Gamay for red, Riesling or a lightly oaked Chardonnay for white, and a bottle of sparkling to start. Half a bottle per wine drinker, plus spares. Keep the big tannic reds away from the cranberry.
The wines above are on our wine page, and we deliver across Toronto and the GTA. Call or text (416) 988-3623. For opening hours over the holiday, see our Thanksgiving long weekend guide.



